She's Out of My League is the best movie comedy of the year... that you HAVEN'T seen. 'League' was one of the best comedies I have seen in a long time. I wanna dive right in.
The movie stars Jay Baruchel as Kirk. Kirk has low self-esteem and is an under-achiever. He had aspirations of becoming a pilot, but ended up working with the TSA with 3 of his loser buddies. He lives at home with his mess of a family and drives a p.o.s. Dodge Neon.
A twist of fate, and a returned cell phone later, he starts dating Molly, played by the beautiful Alice Eve. Molly is the opposite of Kirk in that she's got a great job, a great place to live and connections all over Pittsburgh. Hilarity ensues when the two start to get serious and each person's insecurities come to the forefront.
What I liked:
Baruchel is one of the most talented young actors in Hollywood in my opinion. He is a scene stealer in Knocked Up, held his own with the best of 'em in Tropic Thunder, and is turning a lot of heads in the upcoming The Sorcerer's Apprentice. He knows how to play neurotic, which his character Kirk is in League. Kirk is lovable, he's the loser we root for in chick-flicks, we want him to win.
One of the many great things about The 40 Year Old Virgin and Knocked Up were the supporting characters (Baruchel being one of them in Knocked Up). League is no different; Kirk's family members are classic! His dad is as close to mentally retarded as you can be without being diagnosed, his brother is a wanna be macho man, his sister in-law to be makes fun of him, and his mom is as sweet as apple pie.
Nate Torrence. Devon is the married, goof ball friend that you just love, no matter how annoying he can be. Torrence plays the part PERFECTLY... and remember this, Disney's Aladdin, when you watch the movie, so funny!
What I didn't like:
I hate discussing plots during reviews, but these really bugged me. There were sub-plots involving Kirk's ex-girlfriend and her new boyfriend that just didn't work. There were laughs at their expense, but they took away from the story more than they added to it. Same goes for the family's big trip, also pointless. I understand the writers needed to setup a dramatic climax, but there were so many ways to do it without going down the ridiculous route. The movie is realistic for 90% of the movie, with things that the audience can relate to, and then it just sputters towards the finish. Normally when I like a movie I just tell you guys "it's OK, it's not a big deal"; not this time... why take a chance at ruining the movie with one over-the-top gag.
Overall the movie is, as it's title character is, an under-achiever. The movie grossed 45 million dollars on a 20 million dollar budget. This may sound like a lot, but compare that to mainstream hits like The 40 Year Old Virgin and Knocked Up which grossed 177 and 219 million dollars respectively. Either way, go see the movie! It has a lot of things the made the aforementioned movies a huge success; a great cast, great characters and one-liners galore. Jay Baruchel and Alice Eve shine in this crowd pleasing gem.
Blu-Ray disc special features according to BestBuy.com: Deleted scenes Extended ending Blooper reel Devon's dating show-a hilarious "do's & dont's" guide to dating for guys Commentary by director Jim Field Smith.